I feel the need to further a discussion started recently by writer Maggie Stiefvater. This past month, she went on a rant about the ridiculous overuse of rape within literature. I would say that I couldn't agree more, but in fact, I can agree far more.Like Maggie, I've encountered several books of late which use rape or attempted rape as a means to further the character development of a female character. I could provide examples, but I'm hesitant to do so. My concern isn't so much that I might offend the authors I point out or their readers; it's that I don't think it would be fair. The writers (men and women) I'd point out aren't hacks who haven't the creative talent to craft a well-rounded character with an engaging arc. Many of these books, I've actually enjoyed quite a lot for their other merits. Sadly, these writers have fallen prey to a general acceptance that rape works as a "go-to device" for advancing storylines.
The more I read about the leering gazes and aggressive threats and gestures, the more disgusted I get at the absurd acceptance of this portrayal--and I'm not referring to women being depicted as victims. No, I could mirror Maggie's arguments about the excessive use of rape against women in literature as a means to create character development, but that seems silly. She does a fine job in her recent blog entry, and it's well worth the read. No, my rant focuses on a different side of the coin:
Do we really have such a low opinion of men?
Seriously. Why is it so acceptable to blanketly portray men in such a despicable light? Want to show that a society is violent and brutal? Well then, just make the majority of men sex-driven bruisers who look at women as playthings and baby-makers. Want to make your reader despise the villain? That's simple enough. Just find a convenient opportunity for the villain to disrespect a woman, and mission accomplished. Really, people? You're okay with this?
Before some of you want to say that I'm not being realistic about what men are like, even in our own society, then you'd be mistaken. I've worked for more than eleven years as a 911 dispatcher. In that time, I've talked to murderers, men who've killed women. I've also talked to some women who do a tremendously poor job representing the female half of the population. My job has proven to me that the dark side to equality is that both men and women can suck.
Thankfully, in that time, I've also talked to some people who could bring tears to your eyes for the humanity they display towards others. Damn, I love those calls, but the jaded dispatcher in me realizes, I'm only catching a glimpse of that person's character. Do we really believe the same person who is capable of showing great compassion in one moment is incapable of equally immoral actions? Is it so unrealistic to think we can have a vicious and hated villain in a story who also believes in equality?
Men and women have no shortage of moral crimes they can commit. That's why I ask my fellow writers to challenge themselves. Yes, there will be stories that demand rape as an element, where it might even be appropriate, as difficult as that is to imagine. Stories will require men to be less than they can or should, but we can do better than this. The same minds that can build entire worlds and fill them with souls to entertain and inspire readers can also provide richer ways to unfold those many lives within their tales. We writers have an obligation to ourselves and our readers to reveal all the layers of humanity and not settle for cheap stereotypes that sell humanity short.
Leave a comment




















